There are definitely red herrings in this book. It's funny that you mention that, because I believe last Wednesday's class, someone brought up A Series of Unfortunate Events, and one of those novels was actually the one that taught me what a red herring was.
But yes, you were right. Spencer's mother being Alison's murderer was a red herring. I thought for sure she was the killer because when her mother was talking about Ali, she was subconsciously rubbing her thumb a long the blade of a knife. Spencer also believes her mother is the killer and confronts her about it, but her mother was never even aware that her husband had been cheating on her. The readers, along with Spencer's mother, discover that the affair had been happening for a long time and both Ali and her older brother were in fact Spencer's father's children.
Soon after, all four girls are arrested for Ali's murder, the police think that they all had plotted to kill Alison together. The girls are talking in the interrogation room about how to get out of this mess when an officer comes in and lets them leave. The officer tells them that the real murderer had been discovered after another teenage girl and just been found murdered. The evidence from the second murder led the police to him, where the found an unbelievable amount of evidence that he had also killed Alison DiLaurentis. The man that killed Ali was actually a construction worker that had been building the patio in the DiLaurentis' backyard, the one that Ali's body had been discovered underneath about five years after that. He had also just murdered Jenna Cavanaugh, the blind teenage girl that lived across the street from Alison. Jenna has a special connection to these girls too, because they had accidentally blinded her with her stepbrother's fireworks, and had never told anyone about their guilt. (This all very complicated and intertwined, I know- Sorry!)
Aria, however, finds all of this very hard to believe, because right before she was arrested, she had gone to see a medium. This medium literally seemed to take Alison into her own body. She talked in Alison's voice and had her mannerisms. Aria asked "Ali" who had killed her and the medium wrote it on a small slip of paper because "Ali" said she was too afraid to say the name out loud. When Aria looked at the paper, it said, in Ali's old bubbly handwriting, "Ali killed Ali."
So this is where the novel ends. I'm mad. I want to read the next novel in the series because I'm so anxious to figure out the rest of the mystery, but I literally have no time to do any outside reading. I love these novels, but I feel like they may be too mature to read in a high school setting. I feel like it would be acceptable to recommend this series to some of the more mature students if, as a teacher, I let them choose books to read, but it would be very difficult to teach this novel to a class, or even have the administration allow me to teach it.
Wednesday, September 29, 2010
Wednesday, September 22, 2010
Heartless
I started reading Heartless, the seventh novel in the Pretty Little Liars series for my mystery novel. Because it is the seventh, I wanted to give you a little background information.
The story is about four best friends, Emily, Aria, Hanna, and Spencer. The summer before seventh grade, their fifth best friend, and "clique leader," Ali, went missing. Her body was never found, and the mystery was never solved. However, during their senior year of high school, all four girls begin receiving texts messages, emails, letters, etc, from an "A" threatening to leak their secrets to the rest of the school, secrets that only Ali had known. Her body is then found, and her case takes up again, throwing the girls into the limelight of the news. The girls keep receiving these messages, and trying to figure out who it is, and what REALLY happened to Ali, since "A" is insisting that Ali is still alive, consumes their time
This novel starts right when the girls have just been rescued from a fire started by an unknown in the woods behind Spencer and Ali's old home. Right away, Sara Shepard, the author, throws her readers into suspense and fear. In one chapter (all the chapters are written from a different characters POV) Emily finds herself in an Amish community, after A sends her there to find clues about Ali's whereabouts. I found this funny, because my roommate, a sociology major, is learning about the Amish and I therefore read this part out loud. I thought it was fun that this book was able to bring our two majors together.
I stopped reading after I read such a "WHAT THE HECK?!" moment that I literally threw the book across the room. Spencer is going through her father's old law school yearbooks and finds a picture of a pregnant woman who looks familiar, with her face blurred out. As she continues to go through the yearbook she finds Ali's father, whom she was unaware went to law school with her father. Spencer recognizes him by his nose, which Ali had repeatedly said, had she inherited her father's nose, she would get plastic surgery. After A prompts her, Spencer then creeps through her father's hard drive, and finds two letters that he wrote to Ali's mother. Spencer was totally unaware that they even knew one another. The letter said "Dear Jessica, I'm sorry things got cut short tonight. I can't wait to bea lone with you again." It was written on the day that Ali disappeared. The second letter written to Ali's mother was a wire transfer of an extremely large sum of money going to the "Alison Dilaurentis Recovery Fund."
So of course, after all these discoveries, and watching a lot of Law and Order yesterday, I couldn't stop trying to solve this mystery while I was falling asleep. And now, I think I've figured it out. I believe that Ali is actually Spencer's half sister; they share the same father. It all fits, Ali doesn't have her father's nose, the photograph of the pregnant woman, not Spencer's mom, in the yearbook, the seemingly love affair. And therefore, I'm pretty sure Spencer's mother was the one that killed Ali. She was angry when she found out about the affair and took it out on her husband's lovechild. I love how much this novel lets me use my detective skills.
The story is about four best friends, Emily, Aria, Hanna, and Spencer. The summer before seventh grade, their fifth best friend, and "clique leader," Ali, went missing. Her body was never found, and the mystery was never solved. However, during their senior year of high school, all four girls begin receiving texts messages, emails, letters, etc, from an "A" threatening to leak their secrets to the rest of the school, secrets that only Ali had known. Her body is then found, and her case takes up again, throwing the girls into the limelight of the news. The girls keep receiving these messages, and trying to figure out who it is, and what REALLY happened to Ali, since "A" is insisting that Ali is still alive, consumes their time
This novel starts right when the girls have just been rescued from a fire started by an unknown in the woods behind Spencer and Ali's old home. Right away, Sara Shepard, the author, throws her readers into suspense and fear. In one chapter (all the chapters are written from a different characters POV) Emily finds herself in an Amish community, after A sends her there to find clues about Ali's whereabouts. I found this funny, because my roommate, a sociology major, is learning about the Amish and I therefore read this part out loud. I thought it was fun that this book was able to bring our two majors together.
I stopped reading after I read such a "WHAT THE HECK?!" moment that I literally threw the book across the room. Spencer is going through her father's old law school yearbooks and finds a picture of a pregnant woman who looks familiar, with her face blurred out. As she continues to go through the yearbook she finds Ali's father, whom she was unaware went to law school with her father. Spencer recognizes him by his nose, which Ali had repeatedly said, had she inherited her father's nose, she would get plastic surgery. After A prompts her, Spencer then creeps through her father's hard drive, and finds two letters that he wrote to Ali's mother. Spencer was totally unaware that they even knew one another. The letter said "Dear Jessica, I'm sorry things got cut short tonight. I can't wait to bea lone with you again." It was written on the day that Ali disappeared. The second letter written to Ali's mother was a wire transfer of an extremely large sum of money going to the "Alison Dilaurentis Recovery Fund."
So of course, after all these discoveries, and watching a lot of Law and Order yesterday, I couldn't stop trying to solve this mystery while I was falling asleep. And now, I think I've figured it out. I believe that Ali is actually Spencer's half sister; they share the same father. It all fits, Ali doesn't have her father's nose, the photograph of the pregnant woman, not Spencer's mom, in the yearbook, the seemingly love affair. And therefore, I'm pretty sure Spencer's mother was the one that killed Ali. She was angry when she found out about the affair and took it out on her husband's lovechild. I love how much this novel lets me use my detective skills.
Sunday, September 19, 2010
The Scarlet Letter 3
I finally finished The Scarlet Letter. I didn't like the ending. I know that Dimmesdale has to deal with his own guilt bottled up inside of him for so long, but I feel that he gets out of sinning a lot easier than Hester. As soon as he confesses to being Pearl's father, he dies. To me, that just doesn't seem fair. Hester went YEARS being humiliated by the townspeople and her own scarlet letter. Dimmesdale has his own "scarlet letter" on his body, but it is never seen by the townspeople, and therefore he never has to see their hatred for him. He still is seen as a person to look up to.
This also makes me angry because I feel like Hester gets all of the guilt put on her because she is the woman. It's the same as it is today. The citizens ask Hester repeatedly who the father is, but she refuses to tell them, and I think they feel like seem okay with that. This is because society seems to judge women more harshly for sexual "indecency" then they judge men. I don't really understand why this is so, but I guess it is something that we all have to come to terms with.
And now that I'm done with The Scarlet Letter, I can move on to something a little lighter. I have been reading a series called "Pretty Little Liars" that has actually just been made into a tv show. The newest novel just came out, and it will fit into the mystery genre. Is is okay for me to read this novel, even though it is, I think, the seventh novel in the series?
This also makes me angry because I feel like Hester gets all of the guilt put on her because she is the woman. It's the same as it is today. The citizens ask Hester repeatedly who the father is, but she refuses to tell them, and I think they feel like seem okay with that. This is because society seems to judge women more harshly for sexual "indecency" then they judge men. I don't really understand why this is so, but I guess it is something that we all have to come to terms with.
And now that I'm done with The Scarlet Letter, I can move on to something a little lighter. I have been reading a series called "Pretty Little Liars" that has actually just been made into a tv show. The newest novel just came out, and it will fit into the mystery genre. Is is okay for me to read this novel, even though it is, I think, the seventh novel in the series?
Sunday, September 12, 2010
The Scarlet Letter 2
In response to your comments: There's a passage in the text that says "Her needle work was seen on the Governor; military men wore it on their scarfs, and the minister on his band; it decked the baby's little cap; it was shut up, to be mildewed and moulder away, in the coffins of the dead. But it is not recorded that, in a single instance, her skill was called in aid to embroider the white veil which was to cover the pure blushes of a bride." I also believe that a book being relevant to contemporary life makes it great. Although the time the novel is set in is so different than life today, it is very interesting how many comparisons can be made.
New reading: I have not been able to read as much as I've wanted to. I was hoping to be finished with The Scarlet Letter by now, however, although I'm enjoying and understanding the book a lot more the second time around, it is still difficult due to the language. I am really enjoying Pearl. To me, she's mesmerizing. Her spirit is so different than the child I would have expected her to be. I feel that if I was in Pearl's shoes, an illegitimate child who is picked on, I would curl up and keep away from society. Pearl, on the other hand, almost seems to enjoy the negative attention. I think it's hilarious that she scares the neighborhood children, almost like she is embracing the fact that the townspeople believe her father is "the devil."
I also find it interesting that Dimmesdale is seen as such a wonderful minister. The townspeople don't know that he is Pearl's father and therefore see him as a wonderful public figure in the town; one to look up to and aspire to be. It makes me wonder how different people actually are from the way we see them. How many Dimmesdales do we meet on a regular basis? I'm really enjoying how much this text is making me think, I just wish it was a slightly easier read.
New reading: I have not been able to read as much as I've wanted to. I was hoping to be finished with The Scarlet Letter by now, however, although I'm enjoying and understanding the book a lot more the second time around, it is still difficult due to the language. I am really enjoying Pearl. To me, she's mesmerizing. Her spirit is so different than the child I would have expected her to be. I feel that if I was in Pearl's shoes, an illegitimate child who is picked on, I would curl up and keep away from society. Pearl, on the other hand, almost seems to enjoy the negative attention. I think it's hilarious that she scares the neighborhood children, almost like she is embracing the fact that the townspeople believe her father is "the devil."
I also find it interesting that Dimmesdale is seen as such a wonderful minister. The townspeople don't know that he is Pearl's father and therefore see him as a wonderful public figure in the town; one to look up to and aspire to be. It makes me wonder how different people actually are from the way we see them. How many Dimmesdales do we meet on a regular basis? I'm really enjoying how much this text is making me think, I just wish it was a slightly easier read.
Wednesday, September 8, 2010
The Scarlet Letter
Because I was supposed to have read The Scarlet Letter in high school, and didn't, I wasn't looking forward to beginning the novel for this class. I was surprised, therefore, to realize how interested I became once I started. I can't figure out what it is that is different now; Is it the fact that I've grown up? Do I understand the language better now, after reading literature such as "The Crucible"? Or could it be the fact that there's a new movie coming out Easy A that I REALLY want to see that centers around The Scarlet Letter? I have decided that it must be all of this.
One aspect that I found extremely, for lack of a better word, humorous was the fact that Hester becomes a seamstress. She fashions her own scarlet letter, and uses her gift of sewing to make a living now that she has banished herself to the outskirts of the town. What I found funny, however, was the fact that although the townspeople are more than willing to wear the clothes that she creates, they never ask her to create a wedding dress.
Another thing I found interesting was that I found myself thinking about this novel OUTSIDE of my dorm room. I found myself talking about it to my friends, and trying to discuss with them how different life was back then. Not to make my generations sound like a group of adulterers, but Hester Prynne would have fit in quite well in this time period. Back then, the children of the town were told that Hester was a bad person, and they should not associate with her. The children didn't even fully understand what their parents were saying, but they still took part in humiliating her, just like their parents. These days, we have movies, such as Juno, and television shows such as 16 and Pregnant. Really, what is that saying about our generation and our culture now?
One aspect that I found extremely, for lack of a better word, humorous was the fact that Hester becomes a seamstress. She fashions her own scarlet letter, and uses her gift of sewing to make a living now that she has banished herself to the outskirts of the town. What I found funny, however, was the fact that although the townspeople are more than willing to wear the clothes that she creates, they never ask her to create a wedding dress.
Another thing I found interesting was that I found myself thinking about this novel OUTSIDE of my dorm room. I found myself talking about it to my friends, and trying to discuss with them how different life was back then. Not to make my generations sound like a group of adulterers, but Hester Prynne would have fit in quite well in this time period. Back then, the children of the town were told that Hester was a bad person, and they should not associate with her. The children didn't even fully understand what their parents were saying, but they still took part in humiliating her, just like their parents. These days, we have movies, such as Juno, and television shows such as 16 and Pregnant. Really, what is that saying about our generation and our culture now?
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)