Wednesday, September 29, 2010

Heartless 2

There are definitely red herrings in this book. It's funny that you mention that, because I believe last Wednesday's class, someone brought up A Series of Unfortunate Events, and one of those novels was actually the one that taught me what a red herring was.
But yes, you were right. Spencer's mother being Alison's murderer was a red herring. I thought for sure she was the killer because when her mother was talking about Ali, she was subconsciously rubbing her thumb a long the blade of a knife. Spencer also believes her mother is the killer and confronts her about it, but her mother was never even aware that her husband had been cheating on her. The readers, along with Spencer's mother, discover that the affair had been happening for a long time and both Ali and her older brother were in fact Spencer's father's children.
Soon after, all four girls are arrested for Ali's murder, the police think that they all had plotted to kill Alison together. The girls are talking in the interrogation room about how to get out of this mess when an officer comes in and lets them leave. The officer tells them that the real murderer had been discovered after another teenage girl and just been found murdered. The evidence from the second murder led the police to him, where the found an unbelievable amount of evidence that he had also killed Alison DiLaurentis. The man that killed Ali was actually a construction worker that had been building the patio in the DiLaurentis' backyard, the one that Ali's body had been discovered underneath about five years after that. He had also just murdered Jenna Cavanaugh, the blind teenage girl that lived across the street from Alison. Jenna has a special connection to these girls too, because they had accidentally blinded her with her stepbrother's fireworks, and had never told anyone about their guilt. (This all very complicated and intertwined, I know- Sorry!)
Aria, however, finds all of this very hard to believe, because right before she was arrested, she had gone to see a medium. This medium literally seemed to take Alison into her own body. She talked in Alison's voice and had her mannerisms. Aria asked "Ali" who had killed her and the medium wrote it on a small slip of paper because "Ali" said she was too afraid to say the name out loud. When Aria looked at the paper, it said, in Ali's old bubbly handwriting, "Ali killed Ali."
So this is where the novel ends. I'm mad. I want to read the next novel in the series because I'm so anxious to figure out the rest of the mystery, but I literally have no time to do any outside reading. I love these novels, but I feel like they may be too mature to read in a high school setting. I feel like it would be acceptable to recommend this series to some of the more mature students if, as a teacher, I let them choose books to read, but it would be very difficult to teach this novel to a class, or even have the administration allow me to teach it.

2 comments:

  1. What you say about teaching these texts is pretty insightful. They do sound like they might not work in the classroom for the reasons you mention, but also for something that you refer to. It's nice in the classroom to be able to wrap texts up, get to the end and feel some kind of closure. This series sounds like it would be pretty unsettling for students to all read it. And, ha ha about the red herrings. When you're telling me about these books, it really reminds me of an old TV series, Twin Peaks--did that make it into reruns for your generation? If not, see if you can track one down somewhere. I remember watching it with my friends and making a napkin with all of the characters and relationships because it was pretty convoluted with lots and lots of connections. It also had a pretty creepy tone that was created visually. How about these books? Are they funny? Dark? How does the author do that?

    ReplyDelete
  2. I will definitely have to look into Twin Peaks, sounds very interesting. Maybe I can find it on youtube, or hulu somewhere?
    These books absolutely have a dark tone to them. A lot of the descriptive language that Sara Shepard uses gives off that feel. Somehow, even when the girls are at a highschool party, or something along those lines, she always manages to give it a feeling of foreboding. I think part of that has to do with the fact that she always has something terrible happen when the characters are feeling safe. I guess I'm not quite sure what it is, but I like it.

    ReplyDelete