Wednesday, September 22, 2010

Heartless

I started reading Heartless, the seventh novel in the Pretty Little Liars series for my mystery novel. Because it is the seventh, I wanted to give you a little background information.
The story is about four best friends, Emily, Aria, Hanna, and Spencer. The summer before seventh grade, their fifth best friend, and "clique leader," Ali, went missing. Her body was never found, and the mystery was never solved. However, during their senior year of high school, all four girls begin receiving texts messages, emails, letters, etc, from an "A" threatening to leak their secrets to the rest of the school, secrets that only Ali had known. Her body is then found, and her case takes up again, throwing the girls into the limelight of the news. The girls keep receiving these messages, and trying to figure out who it is, and what REALLY happened to Ali, since "A" is insisting that Ali is still alive, consumes their time

This novel starts right when the girls have just been rescued from a fire started by an unknown in the woods behind Spencer and Ali's old home. Right away,  Sara Shepard, the author, throws her readers into suspense and fear. In one chapter (all the chapters are written from a different characters POV) Emily finds herself in an Amish community, after A sends her there to find clues about Ali's whereabouts. I found this funny, because my roommate, a sociology major, is learning about the Amish and I therefore read this part out loud. I thought it was fun that this book was able to bring our two majors together.
I stopped reading after I read such a "WHAT THE HECK?!" moment that I literally threw the book across the room. Spencer is going through her father's old law school yearbooks and finds a picture of a pregnant woman who looks familiar, with her face blurred out. As she continues to go through the yearbook she finds Ali's father, whom she was unaware went to law school with her father. Spencer recognizes him by his nose, which Ali had repeatedly said, had she inherited her father's nose, she would get plastic surgery. After A prompts her, Spencer then creeps through her father's hard drive, and finds two letters that he wrote to Ali's mother. Spencer was totally unaware that they even knew one another. The letter said "Dear Jessica, I'm sorry things got cut short tonight. I can't wait to bea lone with you again." It was written on the day that Ali disappeared. The second letter written to Ali's mother was a wire transfer of an extremely large sum of money going to the "Alison Dilaurentis Recovery Fund."
So of course, after all these discoveries, and watching a lot of Law and Order yesterday, I couldn't stop trying to solve this mystery while I was falling asleep. And now, I think I've figured it out. I believe that Ali is actually Spencer's half sister; they share the same father. It all fits, Ali doesn't have her father's nose, the photograph of the pregnant woman, not Spencer's mom, in the yearbook, the seemingly love affair. And therefore, I'm pretty sure Spencer's mother was the one that killed Ali. She was angry when she found out about the affair and took it out on her husband's lovechild.  I love how much this novel lets me use my detective skills.

1 comment:

  1. And I love how much you're showing your good reading skills to piece this together. Of course, there is also the trick used and loved by mystery authors of the "red herring." Have you ever heard that expression before? It's about clues or apparent clues that the author drops in to make you think you've figured it all out, when really it leads you away from the truth. Have you noticed that kind of technique in this author's series before? Could that be what you've found? This book seems to offer a "perfect" follow up to the Scarlet Letter since you may have adultery and a private community with the Amish. What connections do you see?

    Keep me posted.

    ReplyDelete