Sunday, September 19, 2010

The Scarlet Letter 3

I finally finished The Scarlet Letter. I didn't like the ending. I know that Dimmesdale has to deal with his own guilt bottled up inside of him for so long, but I feel that he gets out of sinning a lot easier than Hester. As soon as he confesses to being Pearl's father, he dies. To me, that just doesn't seem fair. Hester went YEARS being humiliated by the townspeople and her own scarlet letter. Dimmesdale has his own "scarlet letter" on his body, but it is never seen by the townspeople, and therefore he never has to see their hatred for him. He still is seen as a person to look up to.
This also makes me angry because I feel like Hester gets all of the guilt put on her because she is the woman. It's the same as it is today. The citizens ask Hester repeatedly who the father is, but she refuses to tell them, and I think they feel like seem okay with that. This is because society seems to judge women more harshly for sexual "indecency" then they judge men. I don't really understand why this is so, but I guess it is something that we all have to come to terms with.


And now that I'm done with The Scarlet Letter, I can move on to something a little lighter. I have been reading a series called "Pretty Little Liars" that has actually just been made into a tv show. The newest novel just came out, and it will fit into the mystery genre. Is is okay for me to read this novel, even though it is, I think, the seventh novel in the series?

1 comment:

  1. What do you expect from an ending of a text that you do like!? Do you suppose that for Hawthorne, killing Dimmesdale off is a huge punishment? That is, in the religious community of the text, isn't he forever condemned? Hmmm. You're really paying attention to the societal affects of their various punishments--what people say about them. I wonder if societal expectations was the same when Hawthorne was writing? Do you think so, or are you making the connections to contemporary life? I'd ask you to take the ideas of Scarlet Letter with you into your next book. See what happens when you compare the author's treatment of sexuality and romance in a contemporary setting.

    ReplyDelete