Monday, October 18, 2010

The Shadow Place 2

I just finished The Shadow Place. I'm a little disappointed. I liked it a lot, but I feel like the suspense led to... nothing? I'm not sure how to really phrase this. I wanted there to be SOME kind of change. Not necessarily that Rodney shoots up the school, or kills his father, or himself for that matter, but I feel like something should have been done. The only thing that happens is that Rodney ends up going home, waiting to "turn eighteen" and escape, but clearly, he can't handle his father, especially for another four years, and I want something done about it!
I also was thought it was a little cliche to have Lissa be the ONLY person that saw Rodney at the school function, especially after having that foreshadowing dream. It was a little too much, not "realistic" enough. I felt like I caught myself saying "Honestly? I called that from a mile away," too often.
The only thing I was happy about was the fact that I think Lissa became a better friend. She noticed what Rodney needed, a friend, and tried extremely hard to get it to him. By knowing where to look for Rodney, and trying so hard to find him, Lissa realized how much they really knew about one another and how much they needed each other.
In general, I did enjoy the novel. It was a little difficult to believe sometimes, just because it was so predicable. Which is kind of ironic, in a way. Hmm.
I would recommend the book to others, but I don't think I would teach it in a classroom, for multiple reasons. Not just because of the style, but I think that for students in middle school, like the characters in the book, the novel might go over their heads, and they'll be too focused on the bullying between friends, although they won't learn a lesson, per say, because they're still too focused on "it won't happen to me."

1 comment:

  1. Great points about using this in a class Hannah. One thing I might say in this book's defense is that you're a more sophisticated reader than your students will be. For them, while the text might be predictable, that's what they need as developing readers--to use context clues, foreshadowing, etc., and then see that their predictions come true. I really appreciate that you can move your attention to Lissa and how she changed and developed in the text. Her story could disappear in the high drama of the school, but it doesn't. I don't quite remember the ending, but isn't there a chance that Rodney's mom makes a reappearance? Or, was that his wish, and we know it's not going to happen. Still, I'm pretty sure that the neighbors won't continue to let the abuse continue...no? There are some interesting questions about the adults and their role in this as well. If you find something you like better on this theme, let me know.

    ReplyDelete