I was very happy with the ending of this novel, it was very typical of a YA novel. All the loose ends get tied up, like discovering what really happened at Odwell's; The villain gets sent away forever; Greer gets to stay close to her new friends; Greer and her mother's relationship has never been better. Normally, I don't like endings like this, where everything works out, but I enjoyed it after all the turmoil in the novel.
The one thing I caught myself wondering the whole novel was what the rest of the people participating in the seances were experiencing. Readers know that Madame Camille blacks out, and Greer sees her time at Odwell's, however I'm curious if the others see visions as well, or if they can just sense that something is happening. It would be pointless for the other members to see what Greer sees. Then I wonder if Greer's visions are just helping her warm up to the actual seance, which is where Madame Camille comes in with "Merlin." I guess this would be a good discussion question in a classroom.
I actually really enjoyed this novel and I think it would be an easy novel to teach in a classroom. The symbolism, characterization, setting, tone, everything really, is clearly described through the plot. Therefore, students would be able to pick up on these things easily. Not to mention, it has a very suspenseful (well in my opinion) plot that I think most readers would enjoy.
Hannah, When you think of your future teaching, are you more destined for middle school or high school, do you think? I ask because the books you've been reading lately are more "middle school" texts--partly for length, I'm guessing. But, you're finding the value in them, seeing what they could offer readers, and they seem to be benefiting you as a reader too--that is, you're realizing how you can "see" literary elements so clearly in these simpler texts, and it's allowing you to experience them more fully in more advanced texts too. If you haven't considered middle school, let me suggest that you do.
ReplyDeleteahhh now I'm nervous. I've thought about teaching middle school, but I've always wanted to teach high school. I really like these books though, and would look forward to teaching them. However, I think I'm leaning toward high school mainly because I enjoy their personalities. The wittiness, etc. Hmm... now I'm thinking.
ReplyDelete